Almost immediately after the cancellation of the Nimrod MRA4 was announced in the SDSR, there were persistent rumours of a reinstatement of the capability at some point in the future. What that ‘point’ would be depended on what newspaper you were reading, but the suggestion of anything substantial would have to wait until a suitable period after the cancellation of MRA4.

The MoD had just wasted somewhere south of £4 billion on MRA4, and we should note that at this point, the final costs of cancellation have not yet been announced. So, public discussion of a replacement was therefore about as welcome as a turd in a swimming pool, but time has passed, and almost everyone agrees that for a nation with a long coastline, extensive search and rescue obligations, a submarine based nuclear deterrent and an expeditionary capability that forms the likely core of any future military strategy it is a capability that is not a luxury.

After the usual collection of leaks and rumours, this was confirmed in a number of Defence Committee evidence sessions and subsequently the RAF’s Seedcorn Initiative was revealed in a November 2011 Parliamentary answer;

Angus Robertson (Moray, Scottish National Party)

To ask the Secretary of State for Defence

(1) how many personnel are taking part in the Seedcorn initiative; what the location is of each; and with what equipment they are training;

(2) what capabilities are being maintained through the Seedcorn initiative;

(3) what estimate he has made of the cost to the public purse of the Seedcorn initiative in each of the next five years.

Gerald Howarth (Parliamentary Under Secretary of State (International Security Strategy), Defence; Aldershot, Conservative)

The Seedcorn initiative will sustain the Ministry of Defence (MOD)’s capability to operate high level fixed-wing Maritime Patrol Aircraft (MPA) and maintain the associated skills of its personnel. Qualified RAF aircrew will be on exchange with a variety of Allied MPA forces, where they will maintain their anti-submarine and anti-surface warfare, long-range search and rescue, and Intelligence, Surveillance, Target Acquisition and Reconnaissance (ISTAR) skills.

The estimated cost of the initiative on average is £2.4 million per year for the next five years; this includes salary and allowances.

Retaining skills and MPA knowledge is vital if the United Kingdom is to be in a position to regenerate our own MPA capability at some point in the future.

The number and location of personnel and equipment to be used is as follows:

Location, Aircraft, Number of personnel

Canada, Royal Canadian Air Force Greenwood, CP-140 Aurora, 7

New Zealand, Royal New Zealand Air Force Base Whenuapai, P-3K Orion/P-3K2 Orion, 5

Royal New Zealand Air Force Base Ohakea, Beech King Air B200, 1

Australia, Royal Australian Air Force Base Edinburgh, AP-3C Orion, 4

United States, Naval Air Station Norfolk, Non-flying appointment related to maritime operational staff duties, 1

Naval Air Station Patuxent River, P3C Orion, 2

Additionally, discussions are ongoing with the US Navy on an exchange initiative for fully qualified RAF aircrew to support the US P-8A Poseidon programme.

A total of 33 personnel are serving overseas

So personnel have been cast to the four corners of the world to maintain their varied skill sets, again, another sign, if any were needed, that the maritime patrol capability gap was a temporary one. I think it is apparent that the Seedcorn initiative has a limited life span, there is little point in it if we have no intention of regenerating the capability.

At a cost of £12m for a 5-year programme it has a significant cost, more when one includes other associated costs such as allowances and travel, not included in the answer above.

With the early withdrawal of the MR2 and focus on overland operations before that it is debatable how much realistic ASW and ASuW training had been carried out anyway and with Seedcorn, given the dispositions, again, how many of these perishable skills will be maintained?

Whatever the answer to these questions, in March this year another Parliamentary Answer revealed the following

Mrs Moon: To ask the Secretary of State for Defence pursuant to the answer of 22 March 2011, Official Report, column 947W, on military aircraft, when he expects to publish the findings of the capability investigation on maritime surveillance capability; and if he will make a statement. [92528]

1 Feb 2012 : Column 654W

Peter Luff: The Ministry of Defence has completed its capability investigation into its long term requirements for maritime surveillance capability, but I am withholding the information as its disclosure would, or would be likely to prejudice the capability, effectiveness or security of the armed forces.

In February this year the Commons Select Committee for Defence announced they would be holding a session on just the subject, Future Maritime Surveillance

Despite the delaying and facing saving ‘it’s secret’ position from a few months ago it has been reported that an announcement will be made this month, maybe another one of those ghost announcements that never seem to happen but who knows!

So what of the requirement?

Missions and Requirements

It is a diverse bunch.

SEARCH and RESCUE

At extreme distances the Nimrod provided top cover for vessels distressed and could drop lifesaving equipment as needed.

The UK has a clear international obligation in this regard and is coordinated by the Department of Transport. A good document that details in some depth the UK Search and Rescue framework can be found here.

The key functions of UK SAR are to co-ordinate:

a) Maritime SAR in offshore, inshore and shoreline areas

b) Aeronautical SAR over land and sea

c) Inland SAR

Across the area in the diagram below, covering 1.25 million square nautical miles of sea and over 10.5 thousand nautical miles of coastline

uk-sar-map

With the collapse of the UK SAR PFI in 2011 the SAR PFI in February 2011, in which the Soteria consortium were named as the preferred bidder, an interim or gap contract was placed with CHC and Bristow Helicopters.

The Department for Transport today, Wednesday 8th February 2012, announced that Bristow Helicopters Limited has won the contract to provide Search and Rescue (SAR) services in the north of Scotland.

Bristow will provide SAR services starting July 2013, using Sikorsky S-92 helicopters based in Stornoway and Sumburgh. Operations under the contract are expected to run for four years, until the long-term future provision of such services are secured.

Bristow Helicopters are also part of the FB Heliservices joint venture with Cobham that provides helicopter training to the MoD via the Defence Helicopter Flying School, the contract was extended for another 4 years only last month, a brochure can be read here.

The Soteria website is no longer maintained and the long-term future of UK helicopter SAR still in some doubt but current plans still indicate some sort of public private partnership is preferred, the interim contract runs until 2015, conveniently co-terminus with the next SDSR.

We have been relying on a combination of C130, E3, the French and crossing our fingers to provide long-range SAR cover out to 30W but comparing the number of long-range missions that were carried out before the MR2 was withdrawn and recently using the C130/E3 combination it would seem that the Atlantic has miraculously become a much safer place.

Police helicopters and to some degree the various Air Ambulance aircraft also have some limited part to play in the search and rescue matrix.

OFFSHORE ECONOMIC PROTECTION and SECURITY

The UK offshore environment is a very complex subject, informed by a number of national and international laws and conventions. Broadly speaking, it is divided into 4 areas, internal waters, territorial sea, EEZ and continental shelf.

Other states have many rights within this area such as innocent passage and in some regards the UK has relatively little legislative jurisdiction, fishing for example. A number of international conventions also complicate matters, the OSPAR Convention on waste dumping for example.

uk-eez

Devolution of power to Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales also contribute to the patchwork of legislation that governs the UK EEZ.

British Overseas Territories and Crown Dependencies that are not part of the EU, such as the South Atlantic, also have EEZ’s. Combined, the UK has an enormous EEZ, the fifth largest in the world at over 6.8 million square kilometres.

uk-territorial-waters

Beyond the obvious fisheries protection and pollution monitoring role there is also a more security focussed need for protection of offshore infrastructure such as oil and gas rigs.

Smuggling interdiction, general policing support and other counterterrorism roles complete this broad section and in some circumstances, these might take place some distance from the UK, anti-piracy for example.

INTELLIGENCE GATHERING and AREA SURVEILLANCE

The Nimrod MRA4 had a very capable ESM system and the MR2 at one point in Afghanistan was one of the few platforms able to provide full motion video to ground forces. A maritime patrol aircraft can provide a wide range of sensors and the crew to analyse and disseminate useful intelligence to other elements of any joint force. Their long endurance and ability to operate in non-segregated airspace provides a valuable persistent capability.

Radar, passive electronic detection, electro-optical and sonar technologies are often combined onto a single aircraft.

This is a general requirement that supports the others.

ANTI-SUBMARINE and ANTI-SURFACE WARFARE

There are a number of pure military tasks that might be carried out by a maritime patrol function, namely anti-submarine and anti-surface warfare either supporting an expeditionary force or to protect the UK’s national deterrent.

The current threat levels to the SSBN force could be argued to be relatively low and this might have been instrumental in the risk-based decision to cancel MRA4. We cannot be certain the threat will remain at the current nuisance levels. In an expeditionary context, the rapid advance and proliferation of both quite air breathing submarines and a number of associated technologies mean that submarines will likely comprise a much larger threat in the future. If we are to retain freedom of movement the threat of enemy submarines must be taken seriously.

Modern submarines are very difficult to find and destroy and there is increasing use of improvised and mini submarines that should give naval planners reason for concern.

Operating as part of a complex system of systems, a maritime patrol aircraft would provide outer layer protection.

Anti-surface warfare seems to have almost gone unfashionable in recent times but it remains a valid role.

The basic military requirement is to detect, classify, deter and if necessary, destroy enemy submarines and surface vessels.

It is these roles that differentiate the military from the security and safety and pushes costs up.

Stakeholders

Unlike some military capabilities, there is a veritable menagerie of interested parties, the MoD, Maritime and Coastguard Agency, DEFRA, devolved administrations, EU, various police services and agencies, security services and the UK Border Agency among others.

Also to be considered is the UK’s increasing cooperation with France, India, Brazil, the USA and Japan, whilst not direct stakeholders they all have a direct or indirect interest.

The UK has recently established a single National Maritime Information Centre at Northwood as a single point of contact and information fusion, analysis and dissemination but without a range of assets it is difficult to see its potential maximised.

It is a broad picture made more complicated by the similarly broad span of requirements.

The Span of Requirements Problem

There is a paradox at work here, on the one hand search and rescue is not necessarily a military task and given the MoD is about to (again) outsource the search and rescue helicopter capability to a civilian organisation the MoD would agree, but, a long range military ASW/ASUW patrol aircraft is well suited to the SAR role.

The problem with those ‘do everything’ military aircraft is they are eye wateringly expensive.

For those expecting a P8 Poseidon in UK service, can we reasonably expect them to be providing top cover for a stricken racing yacht whilst carrying an expensive ASW sensor set, weapons and crew?

This is not a new problem, it is one we face across any number of domains, but the trend would seem to me at least to be moving away from one size fits all and outsourcing or civilianising where we can sensibly do so.

Maritime patrol is one of those areas where I think we can do likewise so the fisheries’ protection, maritime security, EEZ protection and Search and Rescue functions can be discharged by a non-military aircraft, thus preserving the high-end roles of anti-submarine and anti-surface warfare for specialist aircraft, in smaller numbers.

fightiness

The diagram above, from an earlier series on a possible RN vessel design, shows the span of requirements, and it is applicable to this area as well.

As we ascend the ‘fightiness’ ladder things inevitably get more complex and expensive but we might argue that the majority of time is spent at the lower rungs, safety and security rather than combat.

Issues and Predictions

We have to be careful about being too specific equipment centric when looking at options, instead of fixating on a like for like Nimrod replacement could a mix of equipment offer more for less?

Questions about the contrast between buying off the shelf or collaborating with our new special friends such as France have to be addressed.

The span of requirements and varied stakeholders complicates matters greatly and the issue of cost cannot be ignored either, in fact, it is central to any solution.

The conventional approach would be simply to buy a dozen P8 Poseidon’s from the USA or enter into a collaboration with France and one or two other EU partners to develop something based on the A320 family (even though Airbus Military no longer list the A319 MPA on their website) to replace the Atlantique and P3’s currently in service.

Buying the P8 would be the quickest option and at least mean that the Seedcorn money was not wasted, going down the Airbus development route means a long period during which the UK would have very little or no capability and those involved with Seedcorn would have likely left the RAF, the money therefore being wasted.

Buying surplus Atlantique’s and operating a joint capability with France does have a certain appeal, but this should be seen as having a limited lifespan, perhaps providing a breathing space for a longer-term development.

So if we are to have a capability within a meaningful time frame and a more or less like for like replacement for Nimrod then the P8 Poseidon is the only practical alternative.

If we look into the future it can be seen that eventually, the E3 Sentry will need replacing and whatever comes after Rivet Joint likewise. The US would obviously look at the Boeing 737 as the donor airframe for these, after the P8 Poseidon. The Royal Australian Air Force had now bought into service the Wedgetail AWACS aircraft. What might put the brakes on the UK eying these large ISTAR aircraft projects is the European dimension and our investment in the A330 for the FSTA programme.

From a commonality perspective, it would make sense to stay with Airbus for these longer-term projects. Even if the A330 is not used as the donor airframe for a maritime patrol or AWAC’s because it could be argued that it is too large, the training and logistics benefits of using the same family of aircraft would be immense.

An MPA, AWACS and ELINT development of an Airbus airframe would necessarily require significant development effort and expenditure but much of this would remain within the EU and UK, delivering a range of industrial benefits and making sure that there remains a viable European alternative to US products, at least in this sector.

Surrendering the market to Boeing is the simple alternative.

For the UK it would seem we are yet again in a difficult place, the sensible military option is to stay with Mr Boeing for MPA, future AWACS and future ELINT but there are powerful industrial and political influences that would point the order book to Airbus.

A simple case of deciding!

This assumes that the ‘answer’ is a simple one for one replacement with no change in the stakeholder mix or span of requirements, there are other options.

I do not think we can have £120m military aircraft using up valuable and finite airframe hours on EEZ protection or search and rescue tasks. With the outsourcing of helicopter SAR the MoD would seem to think along similar lines so the requirement should therefore be split.

The complex patchwork of agencies and other stakeholders is long overdue for rationalisation but there is little political appetite for this and we are therefore unlikely to see the emergence of a coherent national agency with sole responsibility for matters of offshore security and safety.

Perhaps the answer that will emerge is a military capability built around a small scale purchase of P8’s and the other capability areas being met by an extension of the Rotary SAR contract; that would certainly be my favoured option.

Other potential solutions include a hi-lo mix, the P8 with a larger number of twin turboprops like the Airbus Military C295MPA for example and even UAV’s and Lighter Than Air aircraft options may emerge.

Raytheon has suggested the Sentinel may also provide a useful surface search capability; the speed and extreme range of the Sentinel would certainly be useful in the SAR top cover role but these would seem like a case of straw clutching to stave off the announced withdrawal of Sentinel, however much it seems like this will actually not now happen. The French use the Falcon 50 in this role and the US Coastguard operate the Falcon 20, called the Guardian. Incidentally, the USCG also operates the CN235A, called the Ocean Sentry.

Given the risk aversion and severe cost pressures within the MoD I think a short-term purchase of the C235MPA/C295MPA with the longer ranged and more capable P8 scheduled for the medium term aspiration has a good chance of becoming reality. The UK/French Medium Altitude Long Endurance UAV collaborative programme may also incorporate some of the MPA tasks and participation in some form of EU wide sharing should never be ruled out either.

Some might think the C295/235 is a big step-down from MRA4, and they would be correct, but in these financially difficult times it would keep the capability relatively current, provide transit protection for the Vanguard SSBN’s, relieve pressure on other ASW capabilities and provide an economic SAR service.

The problem with the slower turboprop aircraft at long range is transit time, when responding to, for example, a ship distressed, speed counts. On the longer endurance and continual missions where an enduring presence is needed at distance, lower transit speeds mean more aircraft and crew. Turboprops are cheaper to operate, so those costs may be balanced out, as ever, careful examination of the numbers would be required.

But it is a mature and immediately available solution and if seen as a stop gap until a small purchase of P8’s could be made then would it be such a bad decision, better a modest capability that is fully supported and can be built upon than no capability.

There are many conflicting requirements with the maritime patrol and many options to deliver against the requirement, some requiring thought beyond simple equipment choices; that said, equipment would form the basis of any capability delivery.

Equipment options

To provide some basis for discussion the equipment below might be considered as part of a layered maritime patrol capability, both military and civilian, offshore and inshore, short and long range.

They are loosely ordered on cost and complexity, some suitable for the complete spectrum of operations, some only for the safety and security roles.

BOEING POSEIDON P8A

Coming into service with the US, Indian and probably Australian forces this is perhaps the only sensible alternative to the MRA4 with an equally troublesome development history, several compromises and in a number of regards, possessing inferior performance, but it really is the only game in town if we want an off the shelf all singing all dancing long range maritime patrol aircraft. There is little point bemoaning what could have or should have been with the MRA4, whether the MRA4 might have been better than the P8A (I think it would have though), comparing it to the P3 Orion or reflecting on the loss of £4b.

Based on the 737-800 fuselage and 737-900 wing it is a heavily modified and strengthened aircraft with a whole host of the latest and greatest sensors, communications equipment and weapons.

The main advantage of the P8 for the UK, despite probably having to modify certain systems to accommodate national priorities, is the ability to tap into the large development, maintenance and support infrastructure that comes from volumes.

Initial Operating Capability for the US Navy P8A’s is 2013.

The P8 is designed to work in tandem with the Broad Area Maritime Surveillance (BAMS) UAV but it is unlikely the UK would purchase any of these, maybe some integration with Watchkeeper and Telemos would be able to extend the functionality. The Indian versions will come with a Magnetic Anomaly Detector (MAD) that is not present on the US version

The point of the P8 is that it is multi mission but if we consider its roots and the mission focus of the USN and USGC it is very much a military system, the US version of the P8 for example, does not have any provision for SAR equipment.

One of the problems that will prove rather thorny is in-flight refuelling, unrefuelled, the P8 can transit for 1200 miles, remain on station for 4 hours and return. This is much less than the MRA4 and even the P3, although it will be quicker than the latter, in-flight refuelling might therefore be considered something high on the optional extras list. Although the US version does not have an in-flight refuelling capability the base design is equipped with something called the Universal Air Refuelable Receptacle Slipway (UARSSI) that can take fuel from a boom.

Ah, a bit of a problem there.

Given that we opted to go for the stripped down baseline spec for the FSTA, unlike Australia and other customers, it will not be fitted with a boom refuelling system. We will therefore have to modify the FSTA aircraft, modify the P8 or say, oh look, we didn’t need it after all.

Suspect it will be the latter.

Another issue is that of weapons and sensor integration, to reduce airframe stress and fuel burn, and of course, to compensate for the simple fact that 737’s are not designed for low altitude tight turn flying, the concept of operations developed means that anti-submarine detection, classification and attack is carried out at a medium altitude (hence the omission of a MAD detector which is only of use at low levels and to save weight). To support this, the US has developed a wing kit for the Mk 54 lightweight torpedo, called the High Altitude Anti-Submarine Warfare Weapons Concept (HAAWC) that might also be developed to allow a sonobuoy pattern to be deployed from higher altitudes.

The US Navy has also contracted Boeing to develop an air launched UAV that will carry a MAD sensor. The UAV will be based on the Boeing/Insitu Scan Eagle, called the MagEagle Compressed Carriage (MECC) and carried in the bomb bay or wing pylons with recovery by surface vessel or on land. It is an interesting and neat concept, but we don’t use the Scan Eagle.

A lot of work has gone into compensating for the lack of low-level capability, or to provide a stand-off distance for the aircraft, depending on how cynical you are.

The UK does not use the Mk54 torpedo, but the Stingray; therefore, if we are to adopt the same concept of operations we will either have to create such a wing kit for it, or swap to the Mk54.

If we want to integrate other weapons such as Storm Shadow or Brimstone for example, then that would be an additional cost.

The Thales Searchwater 2000MR radar from the MRA4 may be possible to transfer although how this would compare to the Raytheon AN/APY 10 radar fitted to the P8 and cost differentials is uncertain. In addition to the usual collection of HF/VHF/UHF radios, satellite connectivity and Link 16 it will have the Common Data Link system.

The sticker price for the initial Indian P8I buy is $2.1 billion for 8, roughly $260 million each inclusive of initial logistics and support. As ever, these headline process should come with a health warning and extrapolating that figure to a UK purchase price would be fraught with uncertainty, it does provide a useful rough guideline though, £160 million.

So it should be obvious that because the concept of operations with the P8 is different and it has a range of integrated and complimentary systems just buying the aircraft might not be enough.

AIRBUS A319 MPA

Still very much at the PowerPoint stage and not a great deal has been heard about it for some time.

[scribd id=47407175 key=key-202tyqqysoxcvkp8z152 mode=list]

Airbus was attempting to keep the risk low by using its FITS mission system which is already in use on other aircraft. The A319 would be very capable with extra fuel tanks for long endurance, an 8 weapon station bomb bay plus four underwing hard points but at the recent select committee investigation Airbus Military did not even mention it in their written submission, sniffing the obvious mood they instead espoused the off the shelf benefits of the C295/235 MPA.

a319-mpa-airbus

KAWASAKI P1

An interesting outside bet would be the Japanese Kawasaki P1, their indigenous MPA.

Click here for more information.

BREGUET ATALANTIC 3

French forces operate 22 Atlantic 2 from a 27 aircraft group which might be considered comparable to the Orion (although many would argue not) and operating a joint pool with the French might not be an altogether bad idea.

There was some discussion in 2010 of an upgrade to the Atlantic 2’s, including integrating the Thales Ocean Master system, to take the out of service date to post 2030, I think 22 of the 27 will be upgraded. The upgraded ATL2’s are due in service in 2015.

They were also due to be augmented with a long range maritime surveillance platform known as AVion de Surveillance et d’Intervention MARitime (AVISMAR), likely based on a Dassault Falcon 2000.

The turboprop MPA and ultra-long range business jet derived surveillance combination is an interesting take on delivering against the requirement. 

P3 ORION UPGRADE

A number of nations have taken delivery of surplus P3’s and contracted for upgrades.

In 2003, the Germans obtained 8 surplus Dutch P3’s for 271 million Euros, Brazil obtained 12 ex USN Orions for not a great deal and in 2005 contracted with Airbus for a comprehensive upgrade package valued at 320 million Euros.

This would be a realistic option, many airframes are available, but unlikely to be considered for a number of reasons.

AIRBUS MILITARY C295MPA

The Airbus Military C295 MPA is a derivative of the well established C295 twin turboprop transport in service with many forces worldwide. The C295 is a stretched version of the C235 which also has a maritime patrol version; notable users include the US Coastguard. For the MPA version changes made from the baseline transport design includes the installation of the fully integrated tactical system mission suite (FITS) configured with four onboard operator stations, sonobuoy dispenser equipment, magnetic anomaly detector boom, defensive systems, 6 under wing hard points and a FLIR sensor turret.

The FITS mission system is mature and extremely capable, including search radar, electro-optic / infrared sensors (EO/IR), electronic support measures (ESM) / an electronic intelligence system (ELINT), COMINT, a magnetic anomaly detector (MAD), an IFF interrogator, a SATCOM, a datalink and a Link-11. Endurance is reportedly 11 hours or 6 hours on station at 200nm range.

One of the great strengths of the C295 MPA is its versatility, the rear cargo door and palletised mission systems allow the same aircraft to be used for a number of roles. Standard 463L pallet compatibility means that in an expeditionary deployment it can carry its own spares or other stores, as an example.

The basic aircraft might have lost out to the C27 in a number of tactical airlifter competitions with the smallest tactical airlifter due to be in service with the UK being the A400, I have thought for some time that there exists a requirement for something smaller and why not the C235/C295?

It can carry 5 463L pallets or up to 71 personnel, plus it comes with this rather snazzy pallet loading system.

The C235/C295 is a mature aircraft family and Airbus military have recognised when they are on to a good thing and have an interesting development roadmap including the AEW version in the video below;

And even a gunship version

c295-gunship

The C295 is no Poseidon but what if we can’t afford the latter, the flexibility and reasonable capabilities on offer from the C295 at a rough cost of £50m each would seem to be just about right, maybe with a few ultra-long range SARbusiness jet derivatives to provide outer edge surveillance and top cover.

ATR72 ASW

More or less in the same class as the C295 MPA is the ATR72 ASW which is a more combat oriented derivative of Alenia’s ATR72 maritime patrol aircraft, itself a stretched version of the AT42. The launch customer was Turkey and Italy has also started to purchase them in small numbers.

[scribd id=47407142 key=key-4tebnavokinduj9181b mode=list]

Endurance is comparable with the C295MPA, 7 hours at 200nm and is equipped with a rotary sonobuoy launcher, magnetic anomaly detector, defensive system, weapon hard points and a full range of sensors and mission equipment. Although they can be converted to carry cargo there is no rear cargo ramp like the C295 which makes them slightly less versatile but the reported cost of the 10 to Turkey was 260 million Euros.

SAAB 2000 MPA

Equipped with a full suite of sensors, mission and weapons systems the Saab 2000 MPA is in the same category as the C295MPA and ATR72 ASW.

[scribd id=88626045 key=key-28qf5oshy14yyxxmabms mode=list]

EMBRAER EMB 145 MP

Renamed from the P99, the EMB 145 MP fits neatly within the other EMB145 special mission aircraft including the AEW and Multi Intel

Instead of turboprops it is based on the turbofan powered ERJ 145 so this delivers greater transit speeds.

[scribd id=88625430 key=key-1mhvaq4mgutse2yudshp mode=list]

The EMB145 ISR family provides a neat solution for a range of requirements without trying to create a single aircraft that does everything.

ELTA/BOMBARDIER DASH 8

The Bombardier Q Series Multi Mission Aircraft (it has its own web site) has been adopted by a number of users and the Q400 has a speed of 360 knots, longer fuselage and longer range.

Teaming up with Elta, Bombardier are offering the Q400 MPA variant equipped with EL/M-2022A maritime search radar, Electronic Support Measures and MOSP type electro-optical sensor, and, additional communications intelligence COMINT array. The aircraft also mounts a side-mounted gun pod, aft-mounted countermeasures dispensers and side-mounted containers which could carry various stores, for search and rescue missions or other tasks.

SENTINEL R1

If the Sentinel is being withdrawn then the airframes could be repurposed by removing the radar housing and replacing it with a Searchwater 2000 type radar and electro-optical turret.

High transit speeds, altitude and endurance would allow the aircraft to provide outer edge SAR top cover and the sensors, combined with excellent communications equipment could provide benefits in other mission areas.

The logistics system is already in place, the airframes are paid for and if conversion costs were contained then out could provide one part of the maritime patrol jigsaw, although obviously not ASW or ASuW.

Air droppable survival equipment could be door launched for example, there are a number of such equipments available from Airborne Systems and Life Support International

A good overview of the Airborne Systems equipment can be found here

BOMBARDIER 415 MPA

As we move down the fightiness ladder there are many options if search and rescue and maritime security patrolling are the main requirements.

An aircraft with a very long track record the 415 MPA from Bombardier is a versatile aircraft and can be configured to carry a specially designed jet boat (see the video) for sea rescues and able to operate in Sea State 3 conditions.

TECNAM MMA

The Tecnam Multi Mission Aircraft might be on the small side with a modest payload of just less than 150kg but capital and operating costs would be very low, it is claimed they have the lowest operating costs of any similar aircraft.

BRITTEN NORMAN DEFENDER 400

The UK Coastguard, Manchester Police already and MoD already operate the Defender in one form or another, so introduction would not be difficult but whilst cost is very low, performance is not exceptional for the role, perhaps too short legged.

HAWKER BEECHCRAFT KING AIR 350

We already operate the King Air 350 for training and in the guise of the Shadow, using a maritime patrol variant would not unduly stress the logistics system.

Costs are a variable with a wide variety of equipment and support options but performance is good, especially endurance and speed.

VIKING TWIN OTTER GUARDIAN 400

Viking of Canada recently resurrected production of the venerable DHC Twin Otter and have been getting some serious orders from customers as diverse as the Vietnamese Navy and Zimex Aviation in Switzerland.

viking-twin-otter-guardian

There is no doubt that we cannot afford to gap this capability indefinitely but there are a wide variety of solutions available, not all of them obvious, and many influencing factors that serve to make any decisions complex.

Who fancies what then?

 

 

This Post Has 204 Comments

  1. Ant

    @GNB
    Unique Selling Points of US-2, beyond quixotic romance?
    SAR
    Fills the gap, beyond helicopter range out to the limit of our responsibility at 15 degrees West, which we currently do not cover on the grounds that virtually nothing ever happens there, “so that’s OK then, on a management of risk level”. Can perform Rescue in this region, whereas a “sovereignly challenged” MPA lent by our allies, assuming one were available, can only Search, and then direct a ship to Rescue. It can do this in sea states prevalent for maybe 300 days per year. But there is a good chance that the remaining 65/365 days are the ones you actually need it for:- and have you seen the video of crew launching a rubber inflatable raft from the side port??? Good for accessing a life-raft but not a ship’s deck…
    Military
    I tend to agree, but, trying hard:
    1) Collecting and recycling dispensed Sonobuoys at £10,000 a pop?
    Oh hold on: we don’t drop them anymore ‘cos there isn’t an MPA.
    2) Medevac from the fleet at sea?
    3) Delivery or collection of parts/essential items/key staff to the fleet at sea?
    But you can do a parachute-drop from a Hercules, which has nearly twice the capacity, even if it is one-way only. Might be able to land it on a CVF, but it would be a party trick.
    4) Semi-persistent, “semi-organic” AEW by landing next to and refuelling from the fleet.
    Could also be winched aboard/launched from a CVF. In certain circumstances and weather states, maybe. It could however fly higher, further and faster than a Merlin AEW, whilst introducing a new airframe and future cost revenue implication to the mix in a stretched budget.

    In conclusion, I agree not wholly convincing in a Military role, when we are neither in the Pacific islands, nor in desperate need whilst awaiting next Gen UAVs, but would be lovely to see in the SAR/Coastguard role. However the benefit/cost of ownership compared to e.g. CN-235 would probably rule it out here too. Lovely kit though.

  2. x

    @ All

    I forgot I wasn’t posting in the open thread re Syria and war crimes. If only we could edit posts. If only the text was big enough so that we could see where we posting. I remember the good old days……

  3. x

    @ Ant re US-2

    Oh yes! :)

    @ All

    Fell across this today,

    http://21stcenturywire.com/2013/03/10/an-international-war-crime-us-and-british-backed-weapons-airlift-from-croatia-to-syria/

    Reminded me of my time reading IR at uni’ all the talk of war crimes, EU this, UN that etc. All garbage. But this article typifies how many in academia actually view the world. When as I realist I see a heading International and EU Sanctions Against the US, Britain, Turkey, Qatar and Saudi Arabia I struggle to stifle a laugh. International law like fairies only exists when you believe it….

  4. Gloomy Northern Boy

    I can think of no possible practical justification for a modern flying boat for Military use; but if anybody can come up with anything I am all for it!

  5. Swimming Trunks

    @ Ant – You know how to tease a man!

    Hmmmm… Reposition engines above wings? False boat hull (with anti-spray keel)? Add BLC? I like it but I can’t see anyone going for it.

    Another cool idea:

    “Between the World Wars the design of flying boats had proceeded at a fantastic pace. By the mid 1930’s giant four engined flying boats such as the Shorts “C” class and the Boeing Clipper were on the drawing board. The need to keep the propellers clear of the water meant that such designs had deep fuselages, far from streamlined. One way around this problem was to mount the wings and engines high above the fuselage on a pylon or struts, such as in the Consolidated Catalina and Dornier Wal designs, but such installations still produced drag. In 1936 Major J.D. Rennie, chief seaplane designer for the Blackburn Aircraft Company put forward a revolutionary design to meet Air Ministry Specification R1/36. His radical idea was to have the entire bottom of the flying boat hull able to be extended downwards for landing, and be retracted for flight, giving a slim streamlined fuselage and the promise of unprecedented speed for a flying boat.”

    http://freespace.virgin.net/john.dell/blackburn_b20.htm

  6. Ant

    @Gareth
    Airborne Awesomosity indeed. Now how about an A400M conversion mashup?

  7. Ant

    HushKit found a 30min documentary on the Shin Maywa amphibious float plane.

    Perhaps relevant (apart from general interest) for potential Coast Guard and Rescue requirements.
    Interesting for the sequence showing short field take off, and technical aspects of the design, such as use of blown flaps (increases maximum lift coefficient to 7.0), and an anti-spray keel device which prevents water soaking the engines. Allows take off in under 300m at 45 kts and 3m swells. Unfortunately the documentary is a bit historical, and doesn’t discuss the newer US-2 version.

    http://hushkit.wordpress.com/2013/03/07/super-rare-documentary-on-shin-meiwa-px-s-flying-boat/
    See also:
    http://www.shinmaywa.co.jp/english/guide/us2_index.htm

  8. pipistrelle

    Have to agree with many of the previous posts, sadly Solomon’s wisdom will not apply in the present financial climate. The canx of the MR4 is a sadly accepted fact and it will be difficult if not impossible to replace the Nimrod with any A/C that can match its multi mission capability especially now when the purse strings are so tight. The P8 seems a good off the shelf option but but does not deliver the goods in terms of endurance – how many aircraft offer the same coverage factor as the the MR4? I think that maybe a slimmer more cost effective solution has to be a tried and tested turbo-prop with a multi mission capability built in to include a weapon delivery system and a good SAR ability. As always any choice will require 110% from the crews who will operate the new MPA and my best wishes are with these guys and gals whatever the platform.
    (ex CXX)

  9. hokie_1997

    @Observer.

    It’s not really an ‘apples to apples’ comparison wrt manned MPA and UAV aircrew manpower. It depends on the concept of employment, but in general, a long-dwell UAV requires significantly less manpower due to the endurance of the airframe and the ability to structure the aircrew to match the sorties phase.

    Compare a P-3 (300 knots, 10 hrs endurance) providing 24/7 coverage at a range of 1,000 nm versus Global Hawk (300 knots, 28 hrs endurance):

    P-3 ORION: Due to the relatively low endurance of the P-3, you’d need to launch 6 sorties/day to keep one aircraft on-station at all times. Each sortie requires a crew of 10 personnel, for a total of 6 x 10 = 60 personnel.

    And its important to note that the compostion of the P-3 aircrew remains the same regardless of whether the aircraft is launching, in transit, or on-station. All ten of those personnel are committed at all times, even when they are not being fully utilized.

    GLOBAL HAWK: Due to the longer endurance of a UAV you’d only need to launch 2 sorties/day to keep one aircraft on-station. So a lot less sorties… but the real advantage is the ability to ‘right-size’ the crew to match the demands of the sortie.

    Assuming you need 2 personnel to handle UAV launch/recoveries, 1 to handle the outbound transit, 1 to handle the inbound transit, and six-hours ‘shifts’ of 4 personnel each to monitor the on-station aircraft. This works out to a total 2 + 1 + 1 + 24 = 28 personnel.

  10. ArmChairCivvy

    Hi Waddi,

    VC10 and the Herc neck-to-neck now: both have flown once on such a mission
    – must admit that the Parliamentary question was a year ago, so I might be downplaying the mighty Herc in this role

  11. Dave

    An airframe I’ve not seen mentioned is the Bombarider CSeries.

    1) It uses new composite materials so won’t suffer from corrosion issues to the same extent.

    2) It also has fuel efficient engines and the Extended Range variants can go London City Airport to JFK without refuelling.

    3) It is partically built in Belfast

    4) We have an immediate partner – Canada with a fleet of P3C 18+3 that need to be replaced

    5) Bombardier would be interested in developing variants to get the sold airframe numbers moving.

    http://www.casr.ca/id-aerospace-daly-cseries.htm

    Alternatively Embraer could be interesting in devloping one their E-Jets of the 170/175/190/195 into a larger MPA and verstaile AEW/SIGINT airframe as they have experience of this with the smaller ERJ-145

  12. ArmChairCivvy

    Hi CW,

    For a jorno who is told the day before “write something about this” to do that is easy, namely, soon after the SDSR cuts the gvmnt put out a press release where all the “good news” had been stuffed in, including River Joint, even though the request had been passed by the Congress two years before (and was made to plug the hole left by another Nimrod catastrophy… we should number them: AEW, catch fire while airborn, MR4)
    – for most people, a Nimrod is a Nimrod and the references only go a year or two back

    From what Angus has picked up “AVM Green flatly denied any purchase plans (he’s the guy I quoted) for P-8 or anything else” we get another inconsistency as at about the time of the “good news” press release an earmarked £800m to a bn was indicated
    – can’t remember the source for that
    – but there was one, as we had a whole thread running with helpful advice on how best to spend it!

  13. Angus McLellan

    John Hartley: witnesses (can’t remember which) were very dismissive of MSA-ised Sentinel as I recall. Too few airframes with too little space in them (that bit didn’t make sense to me) to be useful. AVM Green flatly denied any purchase plans (he’s the guy I quoted) for P-8 or anything else.

    Rivet Joint was mentioned more than once but mostly as providing a replacement for ESM/ELINT capability lost with Type 22’s retirement. (This was new to me.)

  14. Chris Werb

    The Daily Flail article may be confusing/conflating the already announced RC-135W purchase with a pipedream about purchasing P-8s.

  15. John Hartley

    2 points.
    Flight Global has an offer from Raytheon to upgrade the Sentinel/GlobExp radar for maritime patrol. Plus add a small radar to the RAF KingAir/Shadows, so they can be used for maritime patrol.
    Todays Daily Flail, has an item saying the UK will buy P8s or AirSeeker RC-135 ! for maritime patrol.

  16. Angus McLellan

    Back to sleep then. “There is no requirement to buy an MPA at the moment. … All the work that is done to date is said that if you wanted to, if MoD decide to fill the gap, it would need to buy an aircraft. The question of whether the MoD actually wants to fill that gap or not has not been answered and we see that as being part of the SDSR 2015 timeframe decision.” (section begins with chairman’s question @ 1 hr 39 min-ish)

  17. ArmChairCivvy

    From Mark’s not-quite-MPA link:
    “the system could deliver the UK’s contribution to the NATO Alliance Ground Surveillance system, which will also include an expected five radar-equipped Northrop Grumman RQ-4 Global Hawk unmanned air vehicles.”
    – funnily enough, France has offered Harfang in-lieu of cash, and this idea (a good one, actually) comes hot on the heels

  18. Gareth Jones

    Interesting, What’s the range/endurance of the Sentinel?

    Also the US are planning on getting rid of their Beechcraft; I put a link in he land, air and sea open thread.

  19. Gareth Jones

    The closest idea to it that may be built would be the SKYCAT 1000 – a hybrid air vehicle (HAV) designed to carry up to 1000tons. However, Skycat I believe are now defunct; there parent company (?) is working with LM on similar concepts but I believe their focus is on surveillance, etc, not heavy lift.

    A nice summary of the possible roles of the different Skycat classes (20, 200, and 1000 = max weight of cargo) is here:http://www.worldskycat.com/markets/skypatrol.html

  20. Gareth Jones

    @ Ant – It would appear so; he admits in the comments of the article below that its a invention; I assume this is as well. He’s been on a few blogs talking up his concept of rigid hull airships; Certainly I would of thought people would be talking about an existing airship which could carry 600tons!

  21. Ant

    Gareth J:

    Hi Gareth

    This link was embedded in your Brickmuppet post above:

    http://www.militaryairships.blogspot.co.uk/

    It is allegedly about an exercise called “Harbor Reach”, with plausible transcript from U. S. Senate Defense Appropriations
    Committee hearing dated 6-15 March 1998.
    In it, LTA airships were highly successful at…well you have maybe read the glowing testimony.
    Internet records of these hearings do not extend beyond 2008.
    I cant find anything else about Harbor Reach: is it a wind up?

  22. Gareth Jones

    Interesting report about using airships for Maritime patrol; yes, its for the USCG and yes its a bit old but it’s still interesting:
    http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA089483

    Concludes “The study results indicate a very postive potential for modern airships performing these Coast Guard missions”. Should stress that they are not seen as a replacement for other types of aircraft, but an able addition.

    And there’s this idea of replacing S-3′s with airships:
    http://brickmuppet.mee.nu/weaponsnkit/2813341

  23. Observer

    @SI

    Thanks for the sonobuoy post, the SOSUS GIUK line was what made me suggest the idea in the first place. If it’s not practical, too bad, back to the drawing board.

    I get the feeling that FBOT is just feeling PMSy and is biting everything that irritates him, justified or not. I’ve yet to see proof that the 70s/80s were a low point of ship construction. Unfortunately, it just seems like the industry wandered into someone’s sights at the wrong time of the month.

  24. Fat Bloke on Tour

    SI @ 3.30

    Thanks for the link.
    Regarding the content the crying shame on this project is that the comments made by the hoi poloi were of a higher quality than the comments made in the article by the guy running the show.

    Very interesting that the comments were made by a BWoS employee and not a MOD / RN guy.
    The MOD is currently out sourcing itself to death.
    We should be building what the RN needs not what the UK MIC can make a profit on.

    Finally the ASW shambles continues.
    Why ASW first?
    Surely better to upgrade the 8 best T23 hulls for a useful life.
    Keep the 5 poorest T23s for patrol frigate flag waving and replace these in 2020 onwards.

    Consequently file under – Nimrod / Floating – regarding planning, asset management and VFM.

  25. SomewhatInvolved

    Ix, well then that’s a pity. From this side of the fence our approach follows good precedents. Times have changed since the 80’s. Anyway, proof will be in the pudding, or rather the grey steel.

  26. IXION

    Somewhat involved.

    ‘Nobody has yet to convince HMG or MOD that stretched Rivers, container ships and all the other possibilities here discussed are valid concepts’…

    That’s the point!

    The ‘short fat ship’ debacle in the 80’s which included admitted copyright breach and alleged outright theft, by the govt who ran a smokescreen mis-information plan; shows it’s not a question of being able to convince the govt about stuff like this. They and the RN simply will not hear the argument. It does not compute.

    The RN’s logic is:-

    Warships are sexy fast and sharp pointed things powered at least in part by Gas Turbines. It is simply a decision about how big it needs to be to contain the kit.

    There are hundred of little statements and comments emanating from official, and those close to official, sources, of the ‘We are not buying that! It’s ugly/looks like a rig supply/container ship, etc’; and other heart-warmingly professional, practical based objections for me to quote them all.

  27. SomewhatInvolved

    FBOT, quite aside from the usual BAE sandbagging with pictures and pretty models (I agree by the way), how is it a waste of money? We’ll never know the true cost anyway until well after the first one launches, so no sense worrying about that part. The basic concept of a low cost, high endurance jack of all trades is well proven, and the design pretty similar to many other multi role frigates on foreign drawing boards and slipways. Just because we started with a poor hand, and evolved it into something useful doesn’t mean that what we ended up with isn’t worthwhile.

    I don’t agree that the TA or other kit is second hand. These equipments are continually updated and modified at the dry end, and if the wet end needs improving a new tail can be clipped on very simply. The whole thing is designed to be continually modified and evolved as we gain more and more experience and capability working with the kit. Personally I like the way the MOD has taken on a programme of de-risking the technology before committing to buy a dozen sets and whacking them into new hulls. Anyway, I don’t know what will come first – probably the basic variant to get sea trials out of the way, then the TA gets plugged in later.

    Nobody has yet to convince HMG or MOD that stretched Rivers, container ships and all the other possibilities here discussed are valid concepts. The Type 23’s are getting old and need to be replaced. Would you rather we suffer another capability gap as the frigates go out of service? We may never recover from it. T26 meets the requirement now and we don’t have time to go back to square 1.

    I do agree completely however that BAE are a total bunch of ripoff merchants and deserve nothing but contempt!

  28. Fat Bloke on Tour

    SI @ 1.17

    In other words a complete waste of money.

    The T26 is a sandblasted T23 with space for a couple of containers and BWoS are charging the MOD £127mill for a few nice pictures.
    This really is organised theft from the working class.

    Two questions remains – what version will come first?

    ASW – With the 2nd hand TAS?
    The GP / Patrol version – With the extra pole for flag waving?

    What is the cost and what are we getting for the money?

  29. Gareth Jones

    @ Peter – I like your thinking. There’s two ways to look at it; Gold-platting the transport aircraft fleet or maximising its ultility.

    RE: Towed array tugs. And we’re back to DK Brown… he suggested a similar concept, a modified Castle OPV (this was early ’90’s) which could operate a Merlin (but not hangar), armed with a 30-40mm gun for self-defense and its peace time role, which would be fisheries and other coast guard roles.

    His VLR corvette was 50% bigger to increase range/endurance but had the added bonus of allowing a hangar.

  30. SomewhatInvolved

    Sorry, reread that, the enlarged bow was added to take the 4.5″ gun and associated machinery!

  31. SomewhatInvolved

    ACC,

    Much of the new gear going on the T23’s is basically being de-risked ready for T26. This includes 997, SeaCeptor, and DNA2 (the combat system). Merlin Mk2 goes across as will the S2087 sets and probably the new ESM system when it comes online. MIDAS will also go across. We are endeavouring to ensure as many of the new generation systems are as transferable as possible. Sea Wolf won’t go across obviously, and I suspect the ASCG will be superseded as it isn’t quite what we wanted. I can’t see Harpoon being transferred either, but then it isn’t exactly difficult to do.

    The T23 was originally almost defenceless – no main gun and no missiles. The raised and flared bow was added AFTER the campaign-that-shall-not-be-named when the utility of NGS became apparent again. The ships would have looked ugly without it, I think.

    Type 26 is essentially an evolved T23 because we have found in the latter design a great multipurpose ship with good economy. A basic hull form, efficient propulsion and a good all-round weapons fit leaning towards ASW. The only real change from its predecessor will be space for ISOcontainers, additional boats or whatever modular mission payload we choose to embark.

  32. jedibeeftrix

    good to hear, cheers.

  33. Waddi

    Only a rumour, but from a colleague who lives very close to former BAE Woodford airfield (the MR4A Nimrod factory and where they were crushed). Site has closed down and been sold, however been very heavy Chinook activity over recent weeks. Putting two and two together and probably making five would suggest, as per a few articles, Nimrod sensors weren’t crushed and are being moved somewhere. Perhaps this reduces the odds in favour of the Marshall Hercules plan using the MR4A sensors? As I say highly speculative, but bar the Nimrod only military jet made at Woodford was the Vulcan and must be something valuable and heavy to use Chinooks.

  34. Fat Bloke on Tour

    ACC @ 12.30

    I see you have stumbled upon the “Great T26 Design Mystery” – just what are we getting for our money?

  35. Fat Bloke on Tour

    ACC @ 12.14

    The RN is not a beauty parade.
    It is not about looks, it is about doing the job.

    The Darings were the ships the Tribals Mk2 should have been in 1938 if we had managed to sort out a DP gun mount that did the job it was asked to do.

    Not the menagerie of nearly men and the completely inadequate that the RN was lumbered with 39-45.

    The Counties were hamstrung by a useless AAW system that was designed by “Heath Robinson Systems”. Consequently nice face, shame about the erse.

    As for the T22’s they were the great white hope that failed at their day job – VP props that were too noisy plus they were short legged / all GTs, too small / not beamy enough and lacked a gun.

    Apart from that they were great.

    If that is your idea of success I would hate to see your idea of a failure.

    Post 39 – Only pass marks were the Q+D ASW ships / 1942 Light Fleets / Vanguard (nearly) / ABCH class carriers / Weapons.

    Post 45 – T12 hull form / Invincible / Darings (for persistence) / T23s.

    You would be able to add a few to this list if they had not suffered from the post 1935 RN habit of trying to fit a quart into a pint pot and feeling smug because you had almost made it.

    For the future the RN needs to regain design leadership and it needs new ideas, build efficiency and a less conservative design attitude.

  36. All Politicians are the Same

    Jed, It was FBOT not me who asked why it would be cheaper.

  37. ArmChairCivvy

    Hi SI, millions, yes (not inflation adjusted):
    “In April 2001, the UK Ministry of Defence (MoD) awarded Thales a contract for the development and supply of six S2087 sonar sets with an estimated acquisition cost of £340 million ($652 million). The initial operational capability aboard HMS Westminster (T23-class frigate) was expected by January 2007. As of July 2005, the MoD was negotiating with Thales the acquisition of further two S2087 sets”

    As the T23s are getting new radar, new AD, and have the quiet set-up for propulsion… why would those sets be coming off them (for T26s) any time soon?

  38. Ant

    SI

    Thank you for a genuinely informative post.
    That would be up to or exceeding £900,000 per flight in Sonobuoys for a Nimrod in full cry then?

    Reason being, I saw this a while back:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fulton_surface-to-air_recovery_system
    So should we end up with an MPA based on something with a rear cargo ramp, like a C-130 or A400 for example, some bright entrepreneur could fix a self inflating helium balloon to the arse of the Sonobuoy and save us a fortune!

    Might even pay for the aircraft over its lifetime.

    You heard it here first…

  39. ArmChairCivvy

    Hi FBOT, not signing up to your 70’s/80’s criticism (what is it?)), but
    – 1970 is exactly the cut off in what I see as ‘handsome’ ships: Darings, Counties…
    – T22s were also good looking, in a different way (there definitely was an FI’s lessons learned to take home about them)

  40. jed

    SomeWhatInvolved – I know, I was there :-) it might have been the wrong concept for the 80,s, but using a Ulstein SX119 based RFA with a commercially available active / passive tail, able to land on and refuel a T23’s Merlin when running shotgun for a departing Bomber is not exactly the same concept. It’s obviously a 1 trick pony compared to an MPA, order of magnitude slower and thus covering less area, but a full towed array sonar system is considerably more capable than the Nimrods 300 mixed sonobouys. Plus of course it can undertake EEZ patrol etc.

    APATS – multiple factors at play. Dual role survaillance / SAR aircraft with no military utility on a power by the hour contract, with ground and aircrew who have stable lives living in their own homes etc etc will be cheaper than armed forces personnel for starters. Of course with no defensive aids / EW kit, weapons etc, the bare aircraft is cheaper too

  41. Fat Bloke on Tour

    SI @ 11.14

    The 70’s and 80’s was hardly a golden age for RN ship design. In fact the whole post war era could be included in that statement.

    Lots of hulls, lots of crew and lots of one club golfers, it took the wake up call of the FI’s experience to move things on.

  42. SomewhatInvolved

    Observer and others asking about sonobuoys,

    Going off some old notes but I think a modern HIDAR passive sonobuoy clocks in at about £3000, and a multibeam CAAMBS active sonobuoy over £10,000. Endurance is measured in hours. Nimrod was such a good sub hunter because it could carry 300 buoys and on a proper mission get through the whole lot. Merlins carry 30-40 buoys because you still need them even when you have a dipping sonar – it’s tactics and can say no more. A bathythermographic buoy is also available to measure the sound velocity profile – about £500 I think.

    A static sonobuoy barrier is almost impossible to achieve in oceanic regions. The SOSUS net across the entirety of the North Atlantic, from Greenland to Iceland and the UK (the GIUK Gap of Cold War legend) was epically expensive to deploy, maintain and operate and is probably still so today. Best case it will act as a tripwire telling you something unfriendly has crossed the line – you have still then got to go and find it. Mooring a chain of sonobuoys in 2000-3000m of water is going to be substantially more expensive than an MPA. And where would you lay them? In a barrier around the UK? You then by definition confine your nuclear deterrent behind the line, because the only reason we do advanced ASW in the North Atlantic is to ensure our deterrent hasn’t got a Russian sat behind it waiting to shoot. Or randomly dotted across the ocean? And what about oceanography? The North Atlantic has strong layers which subs can hide in. Unless you set your sonobuoy chain to be either a) depth variable or b) string sensors at a selection of depths, you will struggle to detect the opposition. The Russians have had many years to quieten their boats and they are still very very good.

    Okay, what about active buoys then? Same range problem. Low frequency active sonar perhaps, like 2087? Cost per sonar unit is millions, and you’d have the environmentalists ripping your head off for sonar impact on the environment. Anyway, any sub hearing an active buoy will just drive around it unless you lay a solid wall of the things.

    We had Nimrod for a good reason – you only find nuclear submarines with lots of buoys and a towed array frigate as your backstop. That’s the nature of the game. Any submariners here feel free to put me straight.

    Jed and others, you talk about a cheap hull with a Merlin hangar and a towed sonar to do the job. We looked at something like that years ago during the Cold War – a cheap, low maintenance hull based on a deep sea trawler with a towed array and no self defence ability – in fact they were going to fit the self defence stuff to the oiler that would accompany four such hulls. It was called the Type 23.

  43. Fat Bloke on Tour

    Jackstaff @ 8.11

    The last thing we need to cover the patrol / second string everything is a “stretched River”.

    The “small is the the only way towards cheap” attitude needs to be lost at all costs.

  44. Fat Bloke on Tour

    Jed @ 7.09

    Why would the Civvy Agency be cheaper than a MOD run service?

    Surely there are economies of scale available to the MOD?

    Your point relates very closely to my big issue regarding the Services / MOD – the unit cost of production is ridiculous.

    Any thoughts on why?

Leave a Reply