Think Defence
 
  • Delve into Think Defence
    • Tag Map
    • Links
    • Archives
    • About
    • Contact
  • Revolving Doors
  • Categories
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • Business and Politics
    • Thoughts on the Future
    • History, Humour and Culture
    • News, Images, Videos and Brochures
    • Think Defence Admin and Updates
  • Open Threads
    • Open Thread – Land, Sea and Air
    • Open Thread – Rumble in the CVF Jungle
    • Open Thread – Politics and Business
    • Open Thread – Humour and History
    • Open Thread – Anything Else
    • Open Thread (old)
    • Open Thread II (old)
  • Comments
  •  

Home » Posts tagged 'Nimrod'

  • Nimrod Strikes Back

    • June 15, 2011
    • By Think Defence
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 43 comments

    I am of the opinion that the decision to cancel the MRA4 was the most operationally and strategically illiterate decision of all the operationally and strategically illiterate decisions that populated the SDSR but it seems there is still power in the pile of razor blades that MRA4 became. The source of this power is written evidence to the Defence Select [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • A spare billion for MPA’s ? What shall we buy then…..

    • March 3, 2011
    • By Jed
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 119 comments

    With all the rumour around at the moment about a spare billion being spirited from somewhere, I just thought we should have a little look at some of the possible alternatives for a new Maritime Patrol Aircraft. Just to provoke debate, I thought we could split this into high, medium and low risk. I suppose I could have done it [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • Look Away Now

    • January 26, 2011
    • By Think Defence
    • Business and Politics
    • 45 comments

    Original story here http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-12291372 Have scoured the web for a viewable ‘outside the UK’ version of this if you cannot see the video at the link above Anyway, that will be £4.1 billion please, or in other currencies 4,7 Billion Euros 6.5 Billion Dollars Still, we do have to save £200m per year, wouldn’t want to sacrifice the defence of [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • The Future of the RAF 13 – ISTAR #07 (Maritime)

    • January 23, 2011
    • By Think Defence
    • Thoughts on the Future
    • 49 comments

    I was writing a long piece on the run up to the cancellation but I decided to delete it, Nimrod is gone and is not coming back. Of all the decisions in the SDSR the cancellation of Nimrod is the most insane but maybe insane decisions are needed. It is hard to reconcile the loss of such a versatile piece [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • 4 Billion Quid About to Be Flushed

    • January 21, 2011
    • By Think Defence
    • Business and Politics
    • 62 comments

    As we all know there was never any chance of the Nimrod MRA4 getting a reprieve but the day when they are scrapped is drawing pretty close. When the cancellation was first announced in the SDSR the costs already sunk and costs to cancel were a little unclear. With the passage of time these became clearer, at the point of [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • Nimrod – Is It Too Late

    • January 10, 2011
    • By Think Defence
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 99 comments

    I will be covering Nimrod and its roles in a future post but I received this yesterday and thought it worth publishing, despite the media attention of scrapping the Harriers I think not bringing into service the MRA4 is reckless. I write on behalf of a group of former aerospace workers and supporters in the North West of England, committed [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • What Does £200m a Year Buy These Days?

    • November 30, 2010
    • By Think Defence
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 13 comments

    Binning the Nimrod MRA4 was without a doubt the most idiotic decision to come out of the SDSR, no doubt about that. But if the savings were going to massive then one might have perhaps understood the logic but given that we have already paid for the vast majority of development and productions costs with 1 complete, 1 about to [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • More on Nimrod

    • November 14, 2010
    • By Think Defence
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 33 comments

    Of all the insane decision in the 2010 SDSR, not bringing the MRA4 into service was quite probably the most far reaching in terms of its impact. As the local protest movement moves up a notch the parliamentary questions are getting more and more interesting. Angus Robertson (Moray, Scottish National Party) To ask the Secretary of State for Defence (1) [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • The Nimrod Insanity

    • October 26, 2010
    • By Think Defence
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 69 comments

    Reducing Challenger 2 I can understand, withdrawing the ageing Type 22 frigates I can understand, I can even understand (just) the logic of withdrawing the Harrier, but the decision on Nimrod MRA4 is reckless insanity with only marginal savings. We sometimes get seduced by the ‘sunk cost’ argument where there is a reluctance to cancel something because the huge sums [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • The Nimrod Saga: A Personal Touch Take 2

    • June 22, 2010
    • By Richard Stockley
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 2 comments

    Following on from the previous post about the Nimrod MRA.4 and the two prototypes sat idle at Woodford Aerodrome, I contacted my MP and received the following reply from Peter Luff, the Minister for Defence Equipment, Support and Technology: ‘Thank you for your letter of 18 May enclosing correspondence from your constituent, Mr Richard Stockley, about the MOD’s plans for [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • Quick, Spend It Now

    • March 22, 2010
    • By Think Defence
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 8 comments

    So, General (BOWMAN) Dynamics have been named as preferred bidder for the demonstration phase of the Specialist Vehicle Recce Block 1. The Common Base Platform will also form the basis for a range of other variants. Conveniently forgetting the last 20 years of MoD bungling, Chief of Defence Material, Sir Kevin O’Donoghue, commented on the MoD’s performance; To have reached [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
  • First MRA4 Ready for Training

    • March 11, 2010
    • By Think Defence
    • Land, Sea and Air
    • 1 comment

    The first of the planned Nimrod MRA4′s have been handed over to the RAF to begin crew training. This is the first of 9 ordered but won’t be in full service until 2012 as the whole project has been slowed down to save money. The original order was for 21 aircraft but this has been continually whittled down. As the [...]

    continue reading »

     
     
 

 

Recent Posts

  • Industrial and Technology Matters
  • Consultants on Five Grand a Day at the MoD
  • Parliamentary Answers – to 2nd February 2012
  • A Swarm if Ideas
  • Has the Fat Lass Finished the Chrous
  • A Good Use of 17 Minutes and 22 Seconds
  • UK Military Bridging – Equipment (Medium Girder Bridge)
  • Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land Attack
  • Parliamentary Answers – to 26th January 2011
  • 1 Yorks on Patrol
  • Multi Role Brigades
  • Nigeria
  • Now Thats a Rocket
  • The Bottomless Black Hole
  • Parliametary Answers – to 24th Jan 2012
 

Advert

 

Search Think Defence

 

Recent Comments

  • Chris.B. on Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land AttackI think this throws up an interesting question, one that might help diffuse the tension; Would you rather see a
  • x on Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land AttackFinal fling...... Observer said "I’d rather lose a marine than someone expensively trained." No. Actually the marines are the best
  • x on Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land Attack@ Somewhat I didn't mention fat sailors. If you want to be funny about it it perhaps says something about
  • John Hartley on Cased Telescoping Ammunition Updatechrisb I am starting to wonder if the light cartridge could be lighter, Knight Armament 6x35 comes to mind. In
  • SomewhatRemoved on Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land AttackFor the less ignorant, Type 45 carries the Ultra MFS-7000 active bow mounted sonar and has enough weapons for Lynx
  • SomewhatRemoved on Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land Attackx, I really can't come back at your comments, sorry, because your approach seems so fundamentally divorced from the reality
  • Observer on Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land AttackThis is also why I'm a fan of using LHDs for anti-piracy, low intensity operations, it leaves the Navy battleline
  • Observer on Learning Lessons from Libya, ISR and Maritime Land AttackEmbarked Marine detachment? In a serious situation, I'd rather lose a marine than someone expensively trained. I'd also rather have
 

Upcoming Posts

  • Sea Based Logistics
  • Only a Cynic
  • Squid Wars
  • A Soft Maritime Underbelly
  • The Future of the British Army – Logistics
  • The Future of the British Army – Expeditionary Air Locations
  • A Springer Shaped Waste of £7 Million
  • San Carlos FOB and Black Buck What Ifs
  • The Sad Demise of Defence Journalism
  • The Trident Replacement and Submarine Fleet

Subscribe to Think Defence Don't miss it - Subscribe by RSS.

 
 
 
  • Delve into Think Defence
  • Revolving Doors
  • Categories
  • Open Threads
  • Comments
  •  

WPZOOMDesigned by

Copyright © 2012 Think Defence. All rights reserved.