The Saville Enquiry

So the wait is over, the 12 year, £191 million train wreck put into motion by ‘hand of history’ Tony Blair, has finally hit public domain. Despite some believing it was essential to the peace process, David Trimble, a man who should know, says differently.

The Armed Forces must be held to a higher standard than terrorists, who were intent on torturing and killing innocents in a premeditated fashion, so we must not draw any moral equivalence between the actions of the soldiers and the actions of the IRA, but it is worth noting that the loudest voices of protest seem to be coming from the organisations with close links to the PIRA.

We need to recognise that the soldiers over reacted and made a terrible mistake, resulting in the death of innocents, but sitting in quite calm judgement over the actions of young service personnel, being subjected to acid attack, gunfire, petrol and nail bombs is something we should be very careful of. The enquiry fails to put the events in context, the constant attacks on soldiers and the fact that the area was a complete no go area for the RUC.

General Sir Michael Rose said:

‘How ironic now that the soldiers who brought peace to Northern Ireland are likely to be treated as criminals as a result of this inquiry, while former terrorists like McGuinness and Adams – who did everything to prevent peace – are feted in their roles as ministers.’

Having read the enquiry report it makes a number of puzzling statements that seem to prejudge the evidence or interpret it with singular bias. Despite stating that the soldiers fired the first shot it is widely believed by many credible witnesses that the distinctive first shots were were from a Thompson sub machine gun, the same type of weapon that a certain prominent politician was reported as carrying and a favourite of the IRA at the time. Perhaps if a criminal prosecution against the soldiers was bought and likely held outside Northern Ireland, Martin would be called as a witness and face serious cross examination, rather than the soft soaping he received from Saville.

I wonder if charges of possession of a firearm will follow as well?

Is it really in the public interest to pursue criminal charges against former soldiers, who will now be in their sixties. If it is, then it is equally in the public interest to spend as much time and money on an enquiry into the violent death of every single victim of the troubles; Warrenpoint, Enniskillen, Regents Park, Manchester, Guildford, Omagh etc etc. If it is, then a prosecution against Martin McGuinness should follow.

It is the soldiers of the British Army and members of the RUC, UDR and security forces that held the ring and made both sides of the sectarian divide realise that there was no future in armed terrorism.

As usual, the great and the good will pour liberal quantities of blame off their well teflon’d shoulders and down onto the individuals doing their best, in difficult situations , at the sharp end.

The politicians who placed those young soldiers in Londonderry will of course be absent from any proceedings.

There was much injustice and many victims but Northern Ireland today is a very different place. Whilst the yoghurt knitting folk over at the Guradian and BBC get on with the business of characterising the entire Army in general and the Parachute Regiment in particular, as bloodthirsty murderers, perhaps we might pause for a moment and ask where the last recipient of the Victoria Cross was from.

Cpl Bryan Budd VC; a member of the Parachute Regiment and son of Belfast.

As David Cameron apologised I wonder if we will get an apology from Sinn Fein as well.

It’s time to draw a line and move on.

About Think Defence

Think Defence hopes to start sensible conversations about UK defence issues, no agenda or no campaign but there might be one or two posts on containers, bridges and mexeflotes!

9 thoughts on “The Saville Enquiry

  1. Ann Magee

    I sincerely hope that the author meant to say UDR and not UDA, who did absolutely nothing to help the situation in N. ireland

  2. admin

    Thanks for pointing that out Ann, of course it was UDR.

    Original post duly amended, thanks for spotting that

  3. Phil Darley

    I am biting my lip so hard whilst writing this. How can this report ever be considered to be the truth. It all happened nearly 40 years ago. With the best intentions in the world it is going to be riddled with errors and full of political and religious bias. The role of McGuiness in this and his gloating at the report makes me sick to the core!!!

  4. DominicJ

    PhilD
    I died a little more inside when Cameron praised the report, blackwash.

    My position is rather similar to that I adopt when people accuse the IDF of trying to kill as many Palestinians as possible.
    If the First Battalion of the Parachute Regiment had gone bezerk and wanted to kill as many “poor innocent irish boys” as possible, how did 99.95% of them escape with their lives?

  5. paul g

    oh what a surprise, relatives now demanding criminal prosecutions (not all the relatives admitally) and leading irish figures calling for the para regt to be disbanded to athome for their crimes. Anyone who thought that this report would finally put this event to bed were very sadly mistaken, funny how blair pushed this through then released the terrorist murderers from prison, some only doing the mere pittance of time for their attrocities, then converted to RC seems he spent 13 years trying every avenue to bring this country to it’s knees. Every time i see his smug multi million pound face on tv i have an involuntary action to shout “watch and shoot, targets will fall when hit”!

    sub-note to another thread, what to cut? How about the 24 hr bodyguards to mr £15 million blair paid for by us.
    Rant over , out to you

  6. Euan

    I think anyone actually remotely capable of moving on would have done so by now and the reactions to this report are not that surprising in my mind. I have not read the report and by the comments I don’t think I want or need to read it to know what I would think.

  7. davyh

    As some one who lives in Londonderry I think the report is a joke.

    Am not saying what the soldiers did was right but… the protesters shouldnt of been there, they admitt people in the crowd had weapons and some fired shots after the soldiers opened fire, even martin mcguinness northern ireland education minister admitts having a thompson machine gun on the day and being in charge of the ira at the time but are charges going to be brought against him??

    I think not.

    I just wonder why £190 million was not spent to get justice for the omagh familys etc etc… ohhhh whats the bets the bloody sunday familys are going to get huge payouts now from the goverment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>